We read the reviews you don't.
81 of the 96 supplements have 4.5 stars or more in their web shop. That doesn't help you choose. So we read 15,184 reviews of 15 brands and list, for each product, what buyers praise and what they complain about, with the price per 100 g.
- 15,184reviews read
- 11Dutch web shops
- dailyprice checks
- 0paid placements
XXL Nutrition · Vitamins & minerals · price in shop
Magnesium Bisglycinaat
- +Many say the tablets are easy to swallow, with no aftertaste. 23×
- –Several buyers find the tablets large; one works them into a smoothie. 4×
XXL Nutrition · Vitamins & minerals · price in shop
Vitamine D3 3000 IU
- +The softgels are very small, easy to swallow and leave no aftertaste. 43×
- –The softgels contain beef gelatine, which buyers say isn't clearly stated. 1×
8.5Vitaminstore · Vitamins & minerals · from €17.95 · €0.26 / piece
Super D3 Extra Sterk 75 mcg
- +The softgels are small and, according to many reviewers, easy to swallow. 38×
- –A few buyers report the softgels stick together and to the tub. 3×
8.3Optimum Nutrition · Protein · from €29.99 · €6.66 / 100 g
Gold Standard 100% Isolate
- +Many buyers like the taste, especially vanilla, strawberry and chocolate. 58×
- –Some find the chocolate flavour too bland, artificial or odd. 4×
8.1Body & Fit · Creatine · from €29.99 · €6.00 / 100 g
Creatine Creapure®
- +Reviewers trust the pure Creapure and rate the quality as high. 35×
- –Some buyers say it dissolves poorly and feels gritty. 8×
8.1Bodylab · Creatine · from €39.99 · €8.00 / 100 g
Creatine Creapure® (500 g)
- +Reviewers find Creapure hard to beat at this price. 31×
- –Some say it dissolves poorly or stays powdery. 6×
8.1Solgar · Vitamins & minerals · from €15.95 · €0.14 / piece
Vitamin D-3 25 µg / 1000 IU
- +The softgels are smooth and, according to many reviewers, easy to swallow. 33×
- –At 1000 IU per softgel, buyers often take two or three a day. 8×
8.1Solgar · Omega-3 · from €89.95 · €0.75 / piece
Omega-3 Double Strength
- +Many reviewers taste no fish, not even when burping. 11×
- –Several buyers find it pricey, especially with more than one capsule. 4×
8.0Body & Fit · Creatine · from €6.99 · €2.00 / 100 g
Creatine Monohydraat
- +Reviewers rate the value for money as excellent, sometimes cheaper than other brands. 29×
- –The bag's closure breaks quickly or the bag is awkward to use. 5×
8.0Optimum Nutrition · Creatine · from €15.99 · €5.96 / 100 g
Micronised Creatine
- +Many buyers report it dissolves quickly and without grains. 23×
- –Some find the flavoured versions too sweet, artificial, sour or just nasty. 6×
8.0Optimum Nutrition · Vitamins & minerals · from €19.99 · €0.21 / piece
Opti-Men Multivitamine
- +Reviewers appreciate the broad formula: everything in one tablet. 18×
- –Several buyers find the tablets large; some break them in half. 6×
8.0Upfront · Creatine · from €24.00 · €6.00 / 100 g
Crea PRO
- +Many reviewers say the fine powder dissolves well and doesn't clump. 58×
- –Some see powder sink to the bottom, especially in cold water. 20×
XXL Nutrition · Creatine · price in shop
Creatine (Creapure®)
- +Reviewers find the pure Creapure reliable and sharply priced. 45×
- –Several buyers received packs that expire within a few months. 6×
7.8Body & Fit · Vitamins & minerals · from €9.99 · €0.06 / piece
Vitamine D3 3000 IU
- +Reviewers say the price is low, even compared with the pharmacy. 54×
- –Many buyers are annoyed by the big plastic tub that is only partly filled. 17×
7.8Lucovitaal · Vitamins & minerals · from €7.99 · €0.27 / piece
Vitamine B12 1000 mcg tabletten
- +Many reviewers like the taste of the chewable tablet. 7×
- –Several reviews are empty, nonsensical or posted twice. 2×
7.8Optimum Nutrition · Creatine · from €39.99 · €11.43 / 100 g
Platinum Creatine Plus
- +Many buyers like the taste, especially orange. 21×
- –Several buyers find the flavour too strong at the recommended amount of water. 5×
7.8Vitakruid · Creatine · from €19.90
Creatine Monohydraat
- +Reviewers describe the powder as tasteless and odourless, easy to stir into shakes or dairy. 9×
- –A few buyers find it gritty or had to get used to the texture. 2×
7.7Bodylab · Omega-3 · from €9.90 · €0.08 / piece
Omega-3 (120 caps)
- +Reviewers rate the value for money as good, time and again. 27×
- –A few buyers burp fishy or dislike the taste. 4×
7.7Bulk · Vitamins & minerals · from €7.99
Vitamine D3 Tabletten
- +Reviewers like the high dose in one tablet, so fewer pills are needed. 19×
- –Several buyers waited a long time for delivery or got nothing. 9×
7.7Bulk · Vitamins & minerals · from €7.49
Magnesiumbisglycinaat-tabletten 500 mg
- +Reviewers find the price low for bisglycinate. 21×
- –Some find the tablets large, rough or sharp at the edges. 5×
7.7Vitakruid · Protein · from €49.90
Clear Whey Isolate
- +Almost all reviewers find the lemonade flavour tasty and fresh, especially Tropical. 41×
- –Several buyers find it too sweet and add extra water. 6×
XXL Nutrition · Vitamins & minerals · price in shop
Zink & Magnesium
- +Reviewers find zinc and magnesium in one product handy and well priced. 15×
- –Buyers find four capsules per dose a lot; a tub lasts about a month. 9×
7.6Body & Fit · Vitamins & minerals · from €13.49 · €0.22 / piece
Multi Men
- +Reviewers find the composition very complete: everything in one tablet. 45×
- –The tablet is large and hard to swallow for some. 13×
7.6Lucovitaal · Vitamins & minerals · from €19.99 · €0.22 / piece
Magnesium Bisglycinaat 375 mg (90 tabletten)
- +Buyers have used it for years or stock up when it's on offer. 3×
- –Buyers find the dose high; one buyer reports drowsiness with two tablets. 2×
7.5Bodylab · Vitamins & minerals · price in shop
Multivitamine (120 caps)
- +Reviewers like that it contains a wide range of vitamins and minerals. 9×
- –Many reviews are empty or posted twice, so the evidence is thin. 1×
7.5Optimum Nutrition · Protein · from €28.99 · €4.74 / 100 g
Gold Standard 100% Whey
- +Many buyers like the taste, especially chocolate and vanilla ice cream. 77×
- –Some flavours disappoint: cookies and cream, strawberry, hazelnut, peanut butter. 15×
7.5Optimum Nutrition · Pre-workout · from €39.99 · €10.52 / 100 g
Platinum Pump (cafeïnevrij)
- +Caffeine-free, for evening training or for people who avoid caffeine. 7×
- –Several buyers report strong tingling or itching, especially the first few times. 5×
XXL Nutrition · Creatine · price in shop
Creatine capsules (240)
- +Buyers find capsules much easier than powder: no mixing, no aftertaste, easy to take along. 46×
- –The capsules are large; reviewers say people who find swallowing hard are better off with powder. 27×
7.4Upfront · Amino acids · from €19.00
L-Glutamine
- +Many buyers say it dissolves quickly and without clumps. 42×
- –Many buyers find the taste or aftertaste nasty or bitter. 32×
7.4Vitakruid · Vitamins & minerals · from €9.90
Gebufferde Vitamine C®
- +Reviewers find the capsules easy to take, nicer than powder or chewable tablets. 30×
- –A few buyers find the pills large or hard to swallow. 5×
XXL Nutrition · Vitamins & minerals · price in shop
Multivit (120 tabletten)
- +Buyers say the price per tablet is low for such a complete multivitamin. 24×
- –Several buyers complain about a strong smell on opening, sometimes like rotten eggs. 11×
7.4Yummygums · Vitamins & minerals · from €24.95
Magnesium Gummies
- +Reviewers like the cherry flavour and that it has no medicinal taste. 106×
- –Buyers find the magnesium dose per gummy low and take two or more. 3×
7.3Bulk · Omega-3 · from €15.99
Supersterke omega 3
- +Reviewers praise the high EPA/DHA dose for a low price. 23×
- –A few buyers report fishy burps; one got rancid-smelling capsules. 4×
7.3Lucovitaal · Vitamins & minerals · from €8.99
Magnesium Citraat 400 mg tabletten
- +Buyers have used it for a year or longer and stay satisfied. 3×
- –Several buyers find the tablets big and hard to swallow. 4×
7.3Myprotein · Creatine · from €5.99 · €4.10 / 100 g
Creatine Monohydraat Poeder
- +The unflavoured version tastes neutral and disappears into a shake, tea or quark. 11×
- –Some buyers find the flavoured versions chemical or far too sweet. 12×
7.3Myprotein · Pre-workout · from €32.49
Origin Pre-Workout
- +Buyers call the value for money excellent. 4×
- –The recommended 2 scoops is too much for many; a few report nausea. 7×
7.3Vitaminstore · Omega-3 · from €24.95 · €0.37 / piece
Super Visolie Omega 3
- +Buyers like the high dose of EPA and DHA in one capsule a day. 19×
- –The capsules are large, which is awkward for people who struggle to swallow. 8×
7.3Yummygums · Vitamins & minerals · from €24.95
Multi Gummies
- +Almost all visible reviewers like the taste and soft texture. 145×
- –So candy-like that buyers find it hard to stick to the recommended amount. 9×
7.3Yummygums · Omega-3 · from €24.95
Omega-3 Vegan Gummies
- +Reviewers like the fresh lemon or citrus flavour. 21×
- –Some still smell or taste something fishy or algae-like. 15×
7.3Yummygums · Other · from €24.95
Slaap Gummies
- +The sweet berry or raspberry flavour is called tasty almost everywhere. 40×
- –Buyers call them pricey and sweet, with a craving for more. 3×
7.2Lucovitaal · Vitamins & minerals · from €14.99 · €0.19 / piece
Vitamine D3 75 mcg (80 capsules)
- +Reviewers find the capsules easy to swallow. 2×
- –The capsule contains beef gelatine; one buyer asks whether it's halal. 1×
7.2Lucovitaal · Omega-3 · from €19.99 · €0.67 / piece
Super Omega 3 Visolie
- +Several buyers call the price sharp for the quality. 6×
- –Most reviews just say "good" or "super", with no experience given. 9×
7.2Optimum Nutrition · Pre-workout · from €40.99 · €9.76 / 100 g
Platinum Pre-Workout
- +Many buyers like the taste, especially tropical and fruit punch. 9×
- –A few buyers find the flavour artificial or unpleasant, especially the berry flavours. 3×
7.2Upfront · Creatine · from €9.00 · €3.00 / 100 g
Creatine
- +Many reviewers say it dissolves well, with no clumps or sandy feel. 54×
- –Many buyers report it clumps after a few weeks, especially in the bag. 28×
7.2Vitaminstore · Vitamins & minerals · from €48.95 · €0.73 / piece
Super Multi (multivitamine)
- +Reviewers find the formulation very complete and no longer take separate supplements. 26×
- –Several buyers find the multi expensive or say it has become more expensive. 8×
7.2Solgar · Vitamins & minerals · from €16.50 · €0.25 / piece
Magnesium Citrate
- +Many buyers have used it for years and keep coming back to this brand. 27×
- –The tablets are large; a few buyers can't get them down. 14×
7.2Yummygums · Protein · from €34.95
Collageen Poeder
- +Almost all reviewers like the fruity lemonade flavour. 42×
- –Some find the flavour strong or a bit chemical and dilute it further. 5×
7.1Myprotein · Protein · from €12.99 · €3.67 / 100 g
Impact Whey Protein
- +Classic flavours like vanilla, chocolate brownie, strawberry and blueberry go down well. 16×
- –Some buyers find specials like cinnamon danish chemical or nasty. 23×
7.1Vitakruid · Protein · from €39.90
Vegan Protein Fava Bean & Soy Isolate
- +Many reviewers find the taste good, better than other plant-based shakes. 46×
- –Several buyers find it (too) sweet, even with extra water. 5×
7.1Vitakruid · Vitamins & minerals · from €21.99
Vitamine D3 & K2
- +Many buyers find the dropper drops easy to take and dose. 71×
- –Several buyers report that the cap doesn't close well and the bottle leaks. 6×
7.1Vitaminstore · Creatine · from €15.95 · €6.38 / 100 g
Creatine Monohydraat
- +Reviewers say it mixes well into shakes, water or breakfast with no lumps. 5×
- –The bag is hard to close, so the powder can clump. 2×
7.1Solgar · Vitamins & minerals · from €17.95 · €0.60 / piece
Formula VM-2000
- +Buyers appreciate the complete formula in one tablet a day. 14×
- –Several buyers find the tablets large. 7×
XXL Nutrition · Protein · price in shop
Whey Delicious
- +Many reviewers find the taste good and praise the wide choice of flavours. 144×
- –A good share find certain flavours chemical, sickly sweet or with a strange aftertaste. 40×
7.0Bodylab · Amino acids · from €18.90 · €0.05 / piece
BCAA Mega Caps (400 caps)
- +Reviewers find the capsules easy to swallow, nicer than big tablets. 5×
- –The tub is much too big and mostly full of air. 4×
7.0Myprotein · Hydration · from €11.99
Impact Hydrate
- +Raspberry and lemon-lime are often called nice and fresh. 13×
- –Some say it dissolves slowly or not at all in cold water. 6×
7.0Vitaminstore · Vitamins & minerals · from €19.95 · €0.30 / piece
Super Magnesium
- +Buyers like that several forms of magnesium are in one tablet. 21×
- –Many buyers find the tablets large and hard to swallow. 25×
6.9Vitakruid · Omega-3 · from €24.75
Visolie Forte 1000
- +Many reviewers find the softgels easy to swallow, despite their size. 55×
- –Several buyers get fishy burps or an aftertaste, especially without food. 9×
XXL Nutrition · Creatine · price in shop
Creatine Monohydraat
- +Reviewers call the value for money one of the best. 31×
- –Many buyers report poor dissolving: granules, a gritty feel and sediment. 32×
6.8Body & Fit · Protein · from €35.99 · €3.60 / 100 g
Smart Protein
- +Many buyers find the taste nice and milkshake-like, especially white chocolate and banana. 97×
- –Many buyers find the shake sickly sweet or artificial tasting. 24×
XXL Nutrition · Hydration · price in shop
Elektrolytes
- +Many buyers find mango-peach and mixed berry in particular nice and fresh. 124×
- –Many reviewers find the taste too salty, especially at first. 17×
6.7Body & Fit · Amino acids · from €22.99 · €5.47 / 100 g
Amino Perfection
- +Many buyers find the taste nice and refreshing, especially fruit punch and raspberry. 71×
- –Several buyers taste a chemical sweetener flavour or an aftertaste that lingers. 9×
6.7Bulk · Creatine · from €4.99 · €3.00 / 100 g
Creatine Monohydraat
- +Many reviewers rate the value for money as good. 16×
- –Many buyers find the flavoured versions chemical, sour, bitter or downright nasty. 30×
6.7Upfront · Protein · from €39.00 · €1.18 / serving
Whey Milkshake
- +Many reviewers find it creamy and tasty, especially vanilla, banana and chocolate. 42×
- –Many buyers taste a chemical or sweetener aftertaste, or just find it nasty. 30×
6.5Body & Fit · Protein · from €34.99 · €3.45 / 100 g
Whey Perfection
- +Many buyers find the taste nice and creamy, especially vanilla and chocolate. 106×
- –Many regular buyers find the new version less tasty and more chemical. 29×
6.5Myprotein · Protein · from €20.49 · €3.93 / 100 g
Clear Whey Isolate
- +Many reviewers find flavours like iced tea, peach and raspberry fresh and nice. 21×
- –Many buyers get clumps or sticky residue, even after long shaking. 21×
6.5Vitakruid · Amino acids · from €19.90
NAC 600 mg
- +Buyers call the price per daily dose good, also compared with the pharmacy. 7×
- –Several buyers say taking it between meals takes some getting used to. 4×
6.4Bodylab · Creatine · from €13.50 · €2.70 / 100 g
Creatine Powder (500 g)
- +Reviewers find the value for money very sharp. 24×
- –Many buyers complain that it dissolves poorly and leaves grains behind. 42×
XXL Nutrition · Pre-workout · price in shop
Quake Pre-Workout
- +A large group like the taste, especially Fruit Punch and Cherry Cola. 34×
- –Flavour disappoints several buyers: too sour, too sweet, chemical or cardboard. 10×
XXL Nutrition · Amino acids · price in shop
BCAA Powder
- +Many buyers like the flavoured versions, especially raspberry, apple, tropical and watermelon. 118×
- –Many buyers say the unflavoured version is bitter, chemical and impossible to mask. 8×
6.3NOW Foods · Vitamins & minerals · from €21.95 · €0.18 / piece
Magnesium Citraat 200 mg
- +Buyers appreciate the pure composition without unnecessary additives. 2×
- –A few buyers report loose stools. 3×
XXL Nutrition · Protein · price in shop
Perfect Whey Protein
- +Many reviewers like the taste and find it not too sweet, with water or milk. 117×
- –Many buyers really don't like certain flavours, especially Cookies & Cream. 41×
XXL Nutrition · Protein · price in shop
Green Protein
- +Many buyers find it tastier than other plant-based shakes. 23×
- –Many reviewers find it too sweet; a few are bothered by sucralose. 10×
6.2Bulk · Protein · from €17.99
Pure Whey Protein
- +Many reviewers find vanilla, chocolate, banana and strawberry tasty and creamy. 68×
- –Very many buyers are left with clumps, even after long, hard shaking. 63×
6.2Myprotein · Creatine · from €31.49
Creatine Gummies
- +Many reviewers like the gummies, especially raspberry and lemon. 13×
- –Regular buyers find the new version mushy, powdery or sandy. 11×
6.2Upfront · Hydration · from €9.00 · €0.90 / piece
Electrolytes (10 sticks)
- +Many reviewers find it tasty and not salty, better than other brands. 28×
- –Some find the taste chemical or artificial, especially watermelon. 26×
XXL Nutrition · Protein · price in shop
Whey Isolaat
- +Many reviewers say it dissolves quickly without lumps, even in water. 63×
- –Many buyers taste a chemical, bitter or unpleasant aftertaste. 37×
6.1Myprotein · Amino acids · from €22.49 · €8.00 / 100 g
Essential BCAA 2:1:1
- +Flavours like iced tea, berry burst and lemon lime taste like lemonade. 20×
- –Many buyers say the powder floats and dissolves poorly. 10×
XXL Nutrition · Creatine · price in shop
Muscle Grow
- +Many buyers find most flavours nice, especially cherry, orange, apple and watermelon. 86×
- –Many reviewers find it sickly sweet and are shocked by around 30 grams of sugar per scoop. 26×
5.9Optimum Nutrition · Hydration · from €14.99 · €5.68 / 100 g
Electrolyte Powder
- +Many buyers like the taste and find it refreshing, better than other electrolytes. 32×
- –Several buyers find it far too sweet, including the lemon flavour. 7×
5.9Upfront · Protein · from €30.00 · €0.94 / serving
Clear Whey Limonade
- +Many reviewers find it fresh and tasty, especially chilled or over ice. 35×
- –Very many buyers complain about lots of foam after shaking. 46×
XXL Nutrition · Amino acids · price in shop
Essential Amino Stack
- +Many buyers find the flavoured versions nice and fresh, especially apple, pina colada and raspberry. 94×
- –Many buyers say the unflavoured version tastes bitter, sour or chemical, even in a shake. 24×
5.7Upfront · Pre-workout · from €29.00
Pre PRO 3.0
- +Citrus, strawberry-yuzu and sour cherry are often called tasty and not chemical. 25×
- –Many buyers describe the mango chilli as undrinkable. 26×
5.7Vitakruid · Other · from €12.90
RelaxComplex®
- +Reviewers take it as a fixed evening routine. 4×
- –Many buyers find the tablets very large and hard to swallow. 8×
5.6Bodylab · Protein · from €37.90 · €3.79 / 100 g
Whey Protein (1000 g)
- +Many reviewers find the flavours tasty and creamy, especially vanilla, chocolate and banana. 78×
- –Many buyers find some flavours artificial, chemical or far too sweet. 59×
5.6Bodylab · Pre-workout · price in shop
Pre Workout Booster (300 g)
- +Many reviewers like the taste, especially lemon and orange. 55×
- –The powder clumps or goes hard, even in new tubs. 7×
5.6Vitals · Vitamins & minerals · from €40.95
Elke Dag Mama (één-per-dag multi)
- +Buyers like that one tablet a day is enough. 7×
- –Many buyers find the smell and aftertaste unpleasant, and some compare it to fish feed. 8×
5.5Bodylab · Protein · price in shop
Whey Protein Isolat
- +Many reviewers say it dissolves quickly without clumps, even in water. 53×
- –Many buyers find some flavours artificial, chemical or undrinkable. 46×
5.5Bulk · Hydration · from €21.99
Elektrolyten Poeder
- +Buyers easily mix the unflavoured, sweetener-free version into their own sports drink. 14×
- –Many buyers find the unflavoured extremely salty and undrinkable in water. 27×
5.4Bulk · Pre-workout · from €25.99
Complete Pre-Workout Geavanceerd
- +Flavours such as energy, red bull, berries and tropical go down well with many. 19×
- –Many buyers find the taste nasty, sour, powdery or too sweet. 17×
5.1Orthica · Vitamins & minerals · from €18.95 · €0.28 / piece
Magnesium-400
- +Buyers call it cheap for the high dose. 3×
- –The tablets are large and hard. 2×
XXL Nutrition · Pre-workout · price in shop
Blast! Pre-Workout
- +A large group like the taste, especially cherry, fruit punch and gummy bear. 107×
- –Several buyers report nausea or stomach or bowel problems. 16×
4.9Upfront · Vitamins & minerals · from €19.00
Daily
- +Buyers find it handy to take creatine, collagen and glutamine in one drink. 39×
- –Many buyers find the taste nasty, chemical or medicinal. 46×
XXL Nutrition · Protein · price in shop
Perfect Milk Protein
- +Many reviewers call the shake thick and creamy, like a milkshake. 35×
- –Many buyers complain about poor dissolving, clumps and having to shake for a long time. 14×
XXL Nutrition · Pre-workout · price in shop
Black Label Pre-Workout
- +Buyers say it dissolves easily without clumps. 9×
- –Very many buyers find the taste nasty, chemical or impossible to mask. 46×
XXL Nutrition · Protein · price in shop
Clear Whey Isolate
- +Many reviewers call the taste fresh and nice, like lemonade or iced tea. 153×
- –Several buyers complain about clumps and powder sticking to the bottom. 61×
4.1Bulk · Amino acids · from €34.99
Essentiële aminozuren
- +Flavoured versions such as cola dissolve well according to buyers. 4×
- –Very many buyers find the taste bitter, chemical or downright disgusting. 23×
Frequently asked questions
How is the Supplist score made?
AI reads each product's newest shop reviews plus extra 1–3 star reviews and lists the recurring pros and cons. The score is 70% that verdict, 20% the shop rating compared with other products and 10% how much buyers agree. Brands can't pay for a higher place.
Why does the score differ from the shop's stars?
In the web shops almost everything sits between 4.3 and 4.9 stars, so the number tells little apart. We look at what buyers write, so our scores range from 4.1 to 8.7.
Which supplement scores highest right now?
XXL Nutrition Magnesium Bisglycinaat, at 8.7 out of 10.
Is this medical advice?
No. It's a summary of what buyers say. If you take medication, are pregnant or have symptoms, talk to your GP or a dietitian.