Perfect Milk Protein: what buyers say
How the score works
A creamy, thick and cheap shake, but dissolving and flavour divide buyers sharply.
A plain link to the shop; we get nothing for it. Supplist is owned by simpliSELF B.V., which also sells its own supplements.
AI (Claude) summary of 181 reviews from XXL Nutrition's web shop, read on 16 October 2026, spot-checked by people. We don't verify ourselves that reviewers are buyers. How we use reviews
What buyers like
- +Many reviewers call the shake thick and creamy, like a milkshake. 35×
- +The price is clearly lower than whey or isolate, say many buyers. 23×
- +A large share report it mixes well without clumps. 31×
- +Fans call the flavour mild, not too sweet and not chemical. 11×
What buyers complain about
- –Many buyers complain about poor dissolving, clumps and having to shake for a long time. 14×
- –Gets very thick; stirred into quark or yoghurt it becomes a firm mass. 16×
- –Several reviewers find the taste nasty, chemical or sandy. 9×
- –Others find the flavour bland or weaker than whey. 14×
- –The fine powder puffs up and leaks through the bag or closure. 4×
Watch out
- !Clumps for many; reviewers recommend extra water, a shaker ball or a blender. 6×
- !Flavour divides buyers sharply; some threw the bag away. 4×
- !One buyer reports vomiting and puts it down to the sticky texture. 1×
- !Powder puffs out of the bag; it sometimes arrives covered in dust. 3×
The number is how many of the 181 reviews we read mention this. We only show points about taste, mixing, packaging, price and reported complaints, not about effects.
XXL Nutrition doesn't allow automated price checks. See the price in the shop.
How the score of 4.8 is made
Frequently asked questions
What do buyers think of XXL Nutrition Perfect Milk Protein?
A creamy, thick and cheap shake, but dissolving and flavour divide buyers sharply. Supplist score 4.8 out of 10, number 19 in protein.
What do buyers like most?
Many reviewers call the shake thick and creamy, like a milkshake. (35 of 181 reviews read)
What's the most common complaint?
Many buyers complain about poor dissolving, clumps and having to shake for a long time. (14 of 181 reviews read)
Other protein
8.3Gold Standard 100% Isolate
- Many buyers like the taste, especially vanilla, strawberry and chocolate. 58×
- Some find the chocolate flavour too bland, artificial or odd. 4×
7.7Clear Whey Isolate
- Almost all reviewers find the lemonade flavour tasty and fresh, especially Tropical. 41×
- Several buyers find it too sweet and add extra water. 6×
7.5Gold Standard 100% Whey
- Many buyers like the taste, especially chocolate and vanilla ice cream. 77×
- Some flavours disappoint: cookies and cream, strawberry, hazelnut, peanut butter. 15×
7.2Collageen Poeder
- Almost all reviewers like the fruity lemonade flavour. 42×
- Some find the flavour strong or a bit chemical and dilute it further. 5×
Reviews read on 16 October 2026; prices checked on 16 October 2026. Prices in the shop may have changed since. A summary of what buyers say, not medical advice.