Perfect Whey Protein: what buyers say
How the score works
A widely bought, easily dissolving whey with good value for money, but the flavour varies a lot by variant.
A plain link to the shop; we get nothing for it. Supplist is owned by simpliSELF B.V., which also sells its own supplements.
AI (Claude) summary of 328 reviews from XXL Nutrition's web shop, read on 16 October 2026, spot-checked by people. We don't verify ourselves that reviewers are buyers. How we use reviews
What buyers like
- +Many reviewers like the taste and find it not too sweet, with water or milk. 117×
- +Buyers report it mixes easily without clumps. 53×
- +Reviewers call the value for money and the protein content per scoop good. 32×
- +Easy to work into quark, skyr, oats or pancakes. 15×
What buyers complain about
- –Many buyers really don't like certain flavours, especially Cookies & Cream. 41×
- –Several reviewers taste something chemical or artificial. 20×
- –Flavour is often bland or not what the name promises. 39×
- –Some buyers are left with clumps, sometimes depending on the batch. 26×
- –Loyal buyers complain about big price increases and being excluded from discounts. 10×
Watch out
- !Buyers report that recent bags are watery or taste different. 13×
- !Some find the smell chemical or musty. 6×
- !A few reviewers find it too sweet or too heavy on sweetener. 8×
- !Clumps are mentioned often, including by buyers who were happy before. 26×
- !A few buyers report nausea, bloating or pressure on the chest. 4×
- !According to reviewers the price has risen sharply over the past year. 10×
- !Broken bags, poor closure and delivery problems are mentioned. 17×
- !Whey concentrate contains some lactose; one reviewer mentions isolate as an alternative. 1×
The number is how many of the 328 reviews we read mention this. We only show points about taste, mixing, packaging, price and reported complaints, not about effects.
XXL Nutrition doesn't allow automated price checks. See the price in the shop.
How the score of 6.3 is made
Frequently asked questions
What do buyers think of XXL Nutrition Perfect Whey Protein?
A widely bought, easily dissolving whey with good value for money, but the flavour varies a lot by variant. Supplist score 6.3 out of 10, number 12 in protein.
What do buyers like most?
Many reviewers like the taste and find it not too sweet, with water or milk. (117 of 328 reviews read)
What's the most common complaint?
Many buyers really don't like certain flavours, especially Cookies & Cream. (41 of 328 reviews read)
Other protein
8.3Gold Standard 100% Isolate
- Many buyers like the taste, especially vanilla, strawberry and chocolate. 58×
- Some find the chocolate flavour too bland, artificial or odd. 4×
7.7Clear Whey Isolate
- Almost all reviewers find the lemonade flavour tasty and fresh, especially Tropical. 41×
- Several buyers find it too sweet and add extra water. 6×
7.5Gold Standard 100% Whey
- Many buyers like the taste, especially chocolate and vanilla ice cream. 77×
- Some flavours disappoint: cookies and cream, strawberry, hazelnut, peanut butter. 15×
7.2Collageen Poeder
- Almost all reviewers like the fruity lemonade flavour. 42×
- Some find the flavour strong or a bit chemical and dilute it further. 5×
Reviews read on 16 October 2026; prices checked on 16 October 2026. Prices in the shop may have changed since. A summary of what buyers say, not medical advice.